Wednesday, 6 October 2010

Full Frame or APS-C


Full Frame  or APS-C Sensor

About 6 months ago I was faced with a delemma of which camera to buy. I have always been a canon man and believe through experience that Canon have the slight edge over Nikon for image quality.

I initially wanted to buy the Canon 5D which most of my mates own. This really is a great camera with super high end Iso's and excellent tonal ranges. I had seen the results from this camera and definitely agree with my mates the images are hard to beat for a Full frame camera of this price range.


After a lot of thought and consideration I come to the conclusion that there are pro's and con's for both the two a camera's but eventually I was swayed towards the 7D for quite a number of factors.

  • I have a number of lenses which are Canon EFS lenses which would not fit on a full frame camera, these lense's are built specifcally for a crop sensor camera
  • The 5D is approx £500 more than the 7D
  • I'm an outdoor photographer and sometimes shoot fast subjects the 7D wins hands down at 8fps as opposed to th 5D's 4
  • The 7D has a lot newer design with a whole host of newer features, such as electronic levelling etc
  •  The 7D has a 19 point AF system as opposed the 5D's 9
  •  The 7D has far newer and better HD video system

  •  The 7D includes an Integrated Speedlite Transmitter that allows it to master control of a  wireless flash system enabling a group of different flash heads to be used


Admittedly the 5D does produce more crisper images and noise is less apparent at high end ISO's but for value for money I think I have made the right choice

The 5D is a lovely camera but lacks a lot of the great new features of the 7D. Perhaps we will be seing the 5D Mk 3 soon with all the features included from the 7D
I have heard rumors of the new 5D mk 3 is on the way next year. If all the features of the 7D and the 5D are going to be combined plus even better,newer features are going to be added, I will be putting my name down  for one tomorrow

To summarize the 7D is a great all round camera which is very fast, used more for action and sports photography,brilliant for out door photography but still good for indoor work too

The 5D better has better clarity and tonal ranges,with a great big view finder,less noise,perhaps better suited to studio,wedding and Landscape photography

Shown below is some of my research that I carried out on these 2 cameras. This research was taken from a web site called Digital Rev



Which one to get? Canon EOS  7D VS 5D MarkII


Which one to get? Canon EOS 7D VS 5D MarkII
28 September 2009

What are the factors you need to consider?


Factors
Canon EOS 7D
Canon EOS 5D MarkII
Current stash of Lenses
(Heavy on EF-S?)
For those with lots of EF-S lenses then the 7D is the right choice.For those with mainly EF lenses, it's time to sell off your EF-S and embrace full frame.
Depth of Field (FF or APS-C)Unless you are good enough to tell the difference or shoot lots of landscape where it may be more apparent, APS-C sized sensors are just fine.When Depth of Field is a serious matter of concern.
Continuous Burst Shooting8fps...yes... no contest on this one.3.9fps, suitable for most normal usage but if you need real speed, you need to look over to the 7D.
Telephoto BuffAlways pushing to the limits of your focal range? The 1.6x crop factor will keep sights far out without breaking the bank.Unless you can afford some really long lenses, or don't go far into the telephoto range, you will just have to deal with the trade off between FF's depth of field against the cropped "reach" of the APS-C sensors.
Electronic LevellingIf you need precisely levelled shots for architectural or engineering purposes, then look no further.Not available on the 5D Mark II. Ain't that important? Then you'll be perfectly happy with this camera.
Wireless TransmitterInternally built for convenience but does not support all Canon models. Non-Canon brands? Better get your remote trigger ready...Not shooting with external Canon flash? Then you will need a separate remote trigger anyway.
Pop-up Flash?YES! Maybe not the best results but always there for convenienceNo! In studio, this would be useless anyway and given that you would probably be shooting with L lenses, the flash is just a small investment for better quality
ISO QualityISO up to 12800. Excellent qualities for both. More details available in hands-on review.ISO up to 25600. Excellent for qualities for both. More details available in hands-on review.
HD Movie1080p at 30p, 25p and 24p. Fast 50 or 60p at 720p. S-L-O-W M-O-T-I-O-N here I come!More Depth of Field with larger sensor. 1080p at 30p only. Conversion to 24p is painful for some!
AF System19 cross-type AF points, based on 1-series, enough said.9-point AF + 6 Assist AF points, had received complaints but mostly resolved and gets the job done.

To summarise:
Upgrade to Canon 7D if...Upgrade to Canon 5D II if...
You have a collection of EF-S lenses
You shoot sports or any fast moving activities
You need a built-in flash for convenience
You shoot telephoto & need the crop advantage
You already have a collection of L lenses
You do lots of works in studio
You do lots of ultra wide angle shots
You need an extremely high level of detail in your shots


Whether you choose full-frame vs. APS-C is determined mainly by two factors, cost and the type of photography you do. Generally, full-frame cameras offer higher quality images and better large-format printing capability. APS-C cameras offer greater speed and enhanced magnification by the crop factor. 

Full-frame cameras typically have more, or at least larger, pixels, and these gather more light and capture more information with less “noise.” So full-frame cameras excel in landscape and macro photography and provide more detail, allowing for impressive large-format prints. The slower capture speed of, for example, a Canon EOS 5D, isn’t a problem in landscape or macro photography since light is more controllable as the photographer composes and then captures an image, sometimes using long exposures of the subject. On a full-frame camera, wide-angle lenses perform the same way they do on a 35mm film camera. There’s no crop factor.

When choosing a D-SLR, you have to consider the main subject area you shoot and what level of quality you need.

Shown below are the different crop factors in comparison to a full frame. Full frame refers to the size of the sensor inside your camera in relation to the size of a 35mm negative







Shown below are actual sensor sizes shown in millimeters. As you can see the size of the full frame sensor is considerably larger that the APS-C sensor which can capture more detail and obviously produces a higher quality image. Full frame sensors are a lot more expensive to produce which explains why this type of camera is a lot more expensive that a APS-C sensor type




FormatCorner to CenterLeft/Right Edge to CenterTop/Bottom to Center
Full Frame
36mm x 24mm
21.5mm18mm12mm
APS-C
22.5mm x 15mm
13.5mm11.25mm7.5mm




Shown below are the different sensor sizes from different camera formats.The largest sensor here is a sensor used on a medium format camera. The smallest size sensors are shown from compact digital point and shoot cameras


This diagram shows the comparison of different sensors sizes for the Canon 5 and 7D

Looking at the comparison below you can see that the overall size of the 5D 35mm Full frame sensor is a lot larger than the 7d's APS crop sensor. Obviously the bigger the sensor the more pixel information that can be recorded onto a sensor the more detail and definition will be seen in an image. I have compared the image definition and clarity of my 7D with a friend's 5D and must admit that the 5D wins hands down. Noise is less apparent in the 5D and tonal ranges and colour richness are far superior. Canon have modified the new senor of the 7D but to me it still lacks clarity and sharpness of it's big brother









Sunday, 3 October 2010

Memory cards

The 2 main memory cards that are used for photography nowadays are Compact Flash and Secure Digital. Both cards  are very common nowadays and can be bought from most high street camera shops or computer stores.

The advantages of this type of card are, the cards hold vast amounts of storage data and are the Ideal media for storing vast quantity's of photographs.They range in size from a couple of GB to approx 64 GB for top end storage

Photographer's use these cards to store their photos because they are very small and potable and can be easily carried in a shirt pocket. They are very compact and can be sent through the postal service very cheaply because they are very light in weight. They are relatively cheap to buy and top end cards are very efficient at reading and writing data, which allow fast downloads/upload speeds from a camera and uploading to a computer

The type of memory cards that my camera uses are Compact Flash cards and they come in a variety of different types,speeds and price ranges to suit. The faster the read write speed of the card the quicker response time you will get from your camera and computer

There are mainly 3 main manufactures in this field who produce these cards and they are:

Sandisk
Lexar
Kingston

More information on compact flash cards

This link below is a technical link from the encyclopedia Wikipedia and gives loads of information about compact flash cards and their technical data
Although information on Wikepedia is not verified by any organisation it is a free encyclopidia that anyone can add to or edit. I have always found information on this site to relevant and true




____________________________________________________________

Comparison's
I have used all of the cards above and have found there are some distinct advantages of some cards compared to others.These are outlined below

Sandisk








Shown below are some examples of Sandisk's CF and SD cards









The biggest manufacturer of these type of cards. They have a vast range of cards to suit the amature to the professional. They are very well made rugged cards aimed at all levels and branches of photography

At first I used to use a lot of Sandisk cards. There is a large variety of cards on offer from this company. There are cards to suit all types of digital photography. There are really fast cards which have very fast read write speeds, ideal  for press photographers who need speed at hand instantaneously. 

There are HD(high definition) CF cards designed for  photogrphers who use there camera's for video. You can buy top end very fast cards that cater for HD recording nowadays something that all camera manufactures are using now. Read write speeds have to be very high to record and playback HD movies

There are also slower cards made by this company with slower read/ write speeds tailored for the amateur photographer who's not bothered about speed. These cards are a lot cheaper to buy but downloading large raw files from your camera to your pc can take a lot longer and images take a long time to open

However I have found that a lot of these cards from Sandisk have been counterfeited and have actually bought some of these fake goods. They were supplied by Amazon and they are not sure how these counterfitted goods have infiltrated their stocks. I have 2 faulty cards bought from Amazon and both have crashed my camera. I cannot say if these cards are faulty because they are fakes,it's hard to tell. On two occasions I have lost a vast amount of images and I'm very reluctant to use this make of card again


Follow this link below to Sandisk's website. It shows a variety of video's on the correct card to use for your photography and their specifications






___________________________________________________




Lexar
Another large card manufacture of CF and SD cards. In comparison to all the other cards I prefer Lexar cards. I haven't come across any fakes yet.  I now tend to use a lot of  high end Lexar cards. These cards are very fast and efficient cards and have never let me down. They are competitively priced compared with Sandisk's products and work out a little cheaper for a high quality card. I have moved over to this brand because of all the fakes infiltrating Sandisk's cards

I tend to use the 300x or 400x speed cards which are more than adequote to cater for all my photogrphy needs. In comparison, Sandisk's top of their line pro series cards are the best you can buy way out of my price range





Shown here is one of Lexar's top of the range Cf cards which delivers 90 meg a second download speeds and the technical data taken from their website





Link to Lexar's site



______________________________________________________________


Kingston

The Kingston cards tend to be a lot cheaper cards and haven't got the speeds of the top end cards of Sandisk and Lexar. I have used these cards in the past but now would only use these for geneal use photography as the performance of this type of cards are very slow. They really lack the performance especially for high end HD video shooting or handling very large raw files that most cameras manufactures are producing nowadays




Follow this link to Kingston's page for CF cards



______________________________________________________________


Over all you get what you pay for and I tend to pay the extra for a more efficient faster card. In comparison with all the other makes of CF card, I now choose the high end Lexar cards for my photography. They are very fast, efficient and reliable and also prove very cost effective





Saturday, 2 October 2010




My camera equipment and why I chose it


Shown below is some of my photography equipment that I own and will be using to capture and process my images on this course over the next 16 weeks. Here is a description of my gear and some of the features of the equipment
My Camera’s

Shown below is a list of the camera's that I own. I mainly use my Canon 7d an 18MP 1/60th crop sensor camera. This is a lovely camera with many up to date new features. Some of these  include: very fine definition at 18 MP which produces very clear crisp images. It also features a very fast continuous burst rate 8 fp using raw images and a built in electronic leveling guide/mechanism which you view through the rear LCD. I find this a brilant aid,after some playing around with it, no more need for the spirit levels on my tripod now and no more slanting horizons


  Canon 7D








Specifications










      • 18MP APS-C CMOS sensor
      • 8 frames per second continuous shooting
      • 1080p HD video recording with manual controls
      • 3.0 inch Clear View II LCD screen with 920,000 dots
      • 19-point AF system (all cross-type)
      • 1.0x magnification and 100% coverage viewfinder
      • Wireless flash control
      • Environmental Sealing


A lot of my photography is taken outdoors so environmental sealing  was another great feature and reason why I bought this camera
The camera has the usual 3" LCD rear disply  on the rear and has gone through some  modifications to enhence the brightnesss of the screen when viewing in daylight


This camera has excellent HD recording facilities having 1080p. The clarity of this type of video is outstanding and viewing these video's through an HD tv is excellent. I have taken quite a few video's with this feature and compared to other makes of camera that I have used for video,there is no comparrison


It also features a very usefull function called live view, which enables you to view your photograph before it is taken on the LCD on the rear of the camera. With this feature you actually see exactly how what your photograph will appear after it is shot,which is sometimes not to easy to view throgh the standard viewfinder on the screen what and this is throght the lens


It also features a 19 point auto focus system which makes sure that all of your shots will remain in focus. This feature is customizable with various combinations to suit any photographers needs. This feature is a lot more accurate than most other Canon models and through experience I have found this feature to be very good


Another great feature of this camera is the Lithium -ion battery, it's a LP E6 type which is an improvement from other Canon models. This battery shoots 850 shots with normal use on a sigle charge which I find very usefull. I used to take out 4-5 batteries with me , Now I can cut down the weight of my camera bacg and only take 2 of the camera. I hardly ever have to charge the battery.


This camera has the standard pop-up Canon flash unit which I don't really use. This flash is very harsh and washes out detail when used face on to your subject or very close up. I normally add a flash gun to the hot shoe of the camera or use off flash type flash units mounted away from the camera.
This camera has a built in feature where the main flash can also serve as the remote commander for up to three groups of flashes all controlled by radio,brilliant!


Iso's on this camera are very high ranging from range (100 – 6,400) and is expandable to 12,800. This is  fantastic for me as a night photographer enabling me to capture subjects in their natural light. 


   Canon 400D
My secondary camera backup camera

  • 10.1 megapixel CMOS sensor with improved microlens array, fill factor and lower
  • EOS Integrated Cleaning System
  • Nine point Auto Focus sensor (same as EOS 30D) with F2.8 support
  • Continuous shooting burst up to 27 JPEG and 10 RAW images
  • Single large, bright, 2.5" LCD monitor with 160° viewing angles (horizontal and vertical)




I used this camera for years and won some competitions with it. It's a little outdated now and lacks up to date features of it's modern day equivents such as the 50 or 60 D but I did got some lovely results using it. It doesn't matter how many features a camera has at the end of the day a camera is only a box with a hole in it. Its how you use it that matters and it's all about composition,lighting and your imagination

Another cropped sensor lightweight camera at 10MP it can still produce some nice photos and print fine crisp images up to A3 with no problem. The rear LCD screen seems a little dated now having used 32 now over the past couple of years. The controls on this camera are easy to us

Sensor cleaning is also another advanced feature of this camera.Canon has developed an internal Dust Delete Data system, which can map the position of any visible dust on the sensor. This can then be deleted automatically after shooing  with the latest Digital Photo Professional software.

The exposure mode dial provides access to the various pre-set scene modes and the manual exposure modes. These include, portrait, landscape, macro, sports, night portrait and fully automatic. Semi auto exposure modes including aperture-priority, shutter-priority and full manual are also located on this dial.

Iso's for this camera range from 100-1600 a little small know compared with my 7 D


The Battery's for this camera are still pretty good and at about 400 shots on a single charge isn't bad




See link below for 400D camera review

This link below takes you to Canon's DSLR camera's range 


Fuji F11


My compact point and shoot camera

A great little camera I have used on and off over the past 5 years. Again a lovely point and shoot camera with good resolution. This camera is great to keep in your shirt pocket, I take it with me everywhere. It has an excellent macro producing nearly !:1 ratio images mode and is also excellent for  recording video's, surprising for a camera of this age. It takes XD cards which store huge amounts of photos

It is a 6.3 Mp camera with a built in zoom lens with an aperture range of F2.8-F 5.0. The problem with this type of camera is every shot taken is always in total focus from the camera lens to infinity. There is no room at all for creativity with this type of camera,you cannot blur backgrounds or use this camera creatively.  This a great little point and shoot camera for everyday photography. At the end of the day it does what is say's on the tin

------------------------------------

My lenses


Canon 17-210 USM F4


This is perhaps my favorite lens. It's clarity and definition of tones it produces is second to none. This is a L series lens, which is canons top of it's range series of lenses. It is made of all metal construction and is weather sealed. It's a very fast lens and stopping down to F4 produces some really nice blurred backgrounds which isolate subjects from there backgrounds. It uses USM motors which are built inside the lens which provide very fast auto focusing in a fraction of a second. This is the difference  between lower quality lenses which do not have these motors built into them which make them perform a lot slower

Because my camera using uses a crop sensor, this lens produces a larger focal length than it's maximum zoom of 210 mm stated. The lens will give me giving me a top end range of about 250mm

This lens is fantastic for portraits being able to move in close in to your subjects without them even knowing

This lens was very expensive but I believe in,you get what you pay for. You are paying for top quality lens glass with a precision body. These lenses are used by professionals the world over from studio photographers to press photographers on the move


Canon 17-55 2.8 wide angle zoom




I will be shooting the majority of my landscape images with this lens

To me this lens is really excellent,it,s hardly of my camera. I chose this lens for the clarity of images it produces and it's versatility. With an F stop of 2.8 this is a very fast lens,it is excellent for landscapes having a wide angle of 17mm and it's also great for portraits and general photography. This lens has USM motors in the lens a feature that canon use. These are ultra tiny motors built into the lens which gives very fast auto focusing and very quick reactions,this really important as the killer shot may be missed without this feature

Another feature why I chose this lens is it has IS Image stabilization. This adds a lot of money to the lens but is well worth it. It cuts out camera shake and  allows you to to stop down and hand hold your camera in low light situations with slow shutter speeds without very little blur. I bought this lens for about £600 it now retails at £800,for me it's worth it's weight in gold. The reviews said if this lens had a metal body it would have been classed as a "L" series lens

Specifications







Image sizeAPS-C
35mm film equivalent focal length (mm)27-88
Angle of view (horizontal, vertical, diagonal)68° 40' - 23° 20',
48° - 15° 40',
78° 30' - 27° 50'
Elements/Groups19/12
No. of diaphragm blades7
Minimum aperture22
Closest focussing distance (m)0.35
Maximum magnification (x)0.17 (at 55mm)
Distance informationYes
Image stabilizer3-stops
AF actuatorRing USM²
Filter diameter (mm)77
Max. diameter x length (mm)83.5 x 110.6
Weight (g)645
Magnification with Extension Tube EF12 II0.45-0.231
Magnification with Extension Tube EF25 II1.71-0.51
Lens hoodEW-83J
Soft caseLP1219



Follow the link below for a review of my lens





Tamrom 90mm macro lens



Shown here is my Macro lens which I use to take all of my close up macro shots
I find the performance is decent. The speed of this lens is a little slow compared to my Canon Lenes but the end results are very good producing very crisp clean images
This lens produces a image ratio I:1 which is the equivalent to producing an image the same actual size as the image seen through the viewfinder
I have compared this lens with Canon's 2.8 equivalent and looking at test reports the Canon does have the edge but at the end of the day the Canon is twice the price. I payed £260 for the lens recently, where as the canon is over £500

Specification
  • Focal Length 90mm
  • Aperture f/2.8 (Actually reads f/3 in use)
  • Angle of view 27ยบ
  • Filter size 55mm
  • Construction 10/9 elements/groups
  • Focus type AF/MF
  • Closest focus 290mm (1:1)
  • Weight 405g
  • Dimensions 71.5x97mm
  • Mounts available Canon, Nikon (D), Minolta, Pentax (72E).
  • Tripod bush No
  • Price (SRP) £370
This lens is a lot slower to operate compared with my other other Canon lenses, this is down to the speed of the motors which are built inside the  lens. Top end Canon lenses use USM motors which are very fast where as the AF motor's in this type of lens are less superior producing far slower function ability
   

Brief

My Courses

I have decided to study 3 modules on this course and on completion this will give me a "Diploma in photography and photo imaging". The 3 modules I hope to complete are:


Unit 205 Photo imaging equipment and materials
Unit 310 Photo image output
Unit 312 Working to a photo imaging brief


I have discussed these modules with Steve my tutor and we have decided I will be working to a photo imaging brief on the subject of landscapes, a subject I have never really photographed before, but looking forward to, as this will add another dimension to my photography


The material I will be using for this project will be images I will be capturing over the next couple of months from various locations in and around the country


I am taking a break shortly and visiting the lake district in Cumbria a placewhich I have never visited before.This will be a excellent venue to gather some material for this course. Another place I will be visiting shortly is Whitby gothic festival next month where I want to photograph some street performers and portraits for my second subject of my course. I will hopefully pull in a few landscapes from this area also


Shown below is my camera equipment that I will be using to record all of my images for this course


Canon 7d an 18MP 1/60th crop sensor
Canon 400d  10MP 1/60th crop sensor
Fuji F11 Finepix compact


Canon 70-200 F4 L series Zoom Lens
Canon 17-55 F2.8 L Series Zoom Lens